Books like Soul Searching

If you loved Soul Searching by Lyla Sage, here are 10 books you might enjoy next! If you don’t find what you’re looking for, check out my romance book database where you can search by your dream trope combinations.

Please note as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

1
Wild and Wrangled Lyla Sage
352 pages Book 4 of Rebel Blue Ranch Published by Dial 1 shared tropes
Small town Second chance Friends to lovers Cowboy
2
Beneath the Stars Emily McIntire
400 pages Standalone Self-published 1 shared tropes
Small town Second chance Friends to lovers
3
The Kindred Spirits Supper Club Amy E. Reichert
320 pages Standalone Published by Berkley 1 shared tropes
Ghosts
4
The Ten Year Affair Erin Somers
288 pages Standalone Published by G.P. Putnam's Sons 1 shared tropes
Small town
5
The Mirror Nora Roberts
435 pages Book 2 of The Lost Bride Trilogy Published by St. Martin's Press 1 shared tropes
Ghosts
6
The Cinnamon Spice Inn Harper Graham
320 pages Standalone Self-published 1 shared tropes
Small town Enemies to lovers Second chance Cozy
7
Emily Wilde's Encyclopaedia of Faeries Heather Fawcett
336 pages Book 1 of the Emily Wilde Series Published by Del Rey 1 shared tropes
Small town Animals Cozy Fae
8
Freeing the Wild Paisley Hope
380 pages Standalone Self-published 1 shared tropes
Small town Forced proximity Animals Celebrity
9
Bring Me Back Kristen Granata
350 pages Standalone Self-published 1 shared tropes
Small town Forced proximity Friends to lovers Slow burn
10
Starling House Alix E. Harrow
336 pages Standalone Published by Tor 1 shared tropes
Small town